None of you will be surprised to learn that I'm enjoying the surge of stories and newly discovered documents surrounding the President's National Guard tenure, though of course all of that should be taken with the caveat that it's not what he did back then that's relevant; it's whether he's lying about what he did back then that matters. (The old anti-Clinton distinction, in other words.) But one thing in the coverage of both this scandal and the swift boaters has consistently driven me crazy: television pundits who spend entire shows covering these decades-old stories, and who then have the audacity to complain about the campaigns not focusing on The Issues That Real Americans Care About. (Chris Matthews and guests were doing this last night, but it's a refrain that appears on pretty much every political chat show.)
The next time you hear that complaint registered by a TV personality, I advise you to visit the web sites for Bush and Kerry, and read through the transcripts of their recent speeches and appearances. You will find, almost without exception, that they are talking constantly about Issues That Real Americans Care About: outsourcing, new forms of energy, tax relief, medical liability, the Iraq reconstruction, cargo inspections. Here are two representative excerpts from the last two days:
THE PRESIDENT: Let me tell you something interesting about Wayne's business. He is called a Subchapter S corporation. That is an accounting term, or legal term -- legal term.
MR. LAM: Yes, it's a legal term.
THE PRESIDENT: Legal term. You and I aren't lawyers.
MR. LAM: No, sir. (Applause.)
THE PRESIDENT: A Subchapter S corporation, like a sole proprietorship, pays taxes at the individual income tax level. So when we reduced all rates, individual income tax rates, we're helping Subchapter S corporations like Wayne's. (Applause.) Now, did it help you? The tax relief help at all? I'm sure -- that's called, leading the witness. (Laughter.) Yes, it helped, Mr. President. (Laughter.)
MR. LAMB: Yes, it helped. (Laughter and applause.)
THE PRESIDENT: Let me tell you something. Listen to that rhetoric of this campaign. I'm running against a fellow who promised about $2 trillion -- well, I think maybe a little more than $2 trillion, thus far -- of new spending. So they said, how are you going to pay for it? He said, oh, we're just going to tax the rich; we're going to raise the top two brackets. That's called, taxing the rich. And guess who he taxes? He taxes Wayne. By running up the top two brackets, he's taxing nearly a million, about 900,000, Subchapter S corporations and sole proprietorships.
And from Kerry:
In the last three years, West Virginia lost 11,000 manufacturing jobs. But just today, a report came out that shows we've replaced those good jobs with low wage jobs ones that pay an average of $9,000 less. A lot of them are part-time or temporary and don't provide any health care or benefits. That is wrong. That's George W. Bush and that's why we need a new direction for America.
But if you think it's tough to get by on $9,000 less, you haven't heard the half of it. Health care costs are up, tuition is up, child care costs are up, gas prices are up, and family income has fallen. So people are working two jobs, three jobs, working nights and weekends, just to make ends meet.
Four years ago, George W. Bush told us he wanted to create an economy where there was high-paying, high-quality work for everyone. He now says prosperity has returned and we've turned the corner. Well, that's just plain wrong.
No mention of the National Guard, no mention of the swift boats. If the media wants a substantive campaign, it's sitting right in front of them, waiting to be covered. But of course tax breaks for S Corporations don't make very good television, which is why they invariably don't get covered. And that in itself is fine: television is in the business of improving ratings, not civic discourse. Just don't complain about our declining political discourse when you're the one dragging it down.